• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

RJS LAW - Tax and Estate Planning

RJS LAW: San Diego Tax Attorney | IRS | FTB | CPA | California

Header Right

SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA’S FINEST
LAW FIRM

COMPLIMENTARY CASE EVALUATION

SAN DIEGO
(619) 595-1655
El CAJON
(619) 777-7700
  • Home
  • About
    • Ronson J. Shamoun, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Chandara Diep, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Devon J. Arabo, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Brian M. Malloy, Esq.
    • Andrea Cisneros Valdez, Esq., LL.M.
    • Sam Imandoust, ESQ., LL.M
    • Lauren Suarez, ESQ., LL.M.
    • John I. Forry, Esq.
    • Martin Schainbaum, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Kaveh Imandoust, JD, MBT, CPA
    • Joseph Cole, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Christopher Engelmann, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Remy Hogan, Esq., LL.M.
    • Steve S. Mattia, Esq.
    • Dod Ghassemkhani, ESQ.
    • Vincent Renda, Esq.
    • Pedro Bernal, Esq.
    • Sabri P. Shamoun 1938-2023
    • Melanie M. Shamoun
    • Renae Arabo
    • Hilary Dargavell
    • Sandie Portilla
    • Lupita C. Torres
    • Jewell Cornejo
    • Kesia Belford
    • Danielle N. Misleh
    • Judith G. Jeremie, JD
    • Rebecca Shuman
    • Michael Lutzky, CPA
    • Gianna Iskander
  • Practices
    • Tax
      • IRS TAX MATTERS
        • IRS Appeals
          • IRS Appeals Process
          • Contesting an IRS Levy
          • Why Retain RJS LAW for IRS Appeals
          • 4 Tips For Navigating The IRS Rapid Appeals Process
        • IRS AUDITS
          • IRS Correspondence Audits
          • What are IRS Field Audits?
          • Initial IRS Compliance Center Audits
          • IRS Office Audits
          • What happens in an IRS Audit?
          • Taxpayer Rights Under IRS Publication 1
          • IRS Warns Taxpayers About Scam
        • NOTICES
          • IRS Notices
          • IRS Letters
          • FTB Notices
          • Avisos en Español
        • IRS Collections
          • Avoiding and Eliminating IRS Tax Liens
          • Collection Due Process Hearing
          • CP 501 – IRS Notice
          • Failure to file a tax return: What happens?
          • How the IRS calculates interest
          • How to get a tax levy released
          • ACS – Automated Collection System
          • IRS Collections Process
          • IRS Interest Abatement
          • IRS Revenue Officers
          • Jeopardy Assessments and Jeopardy Levies
          • National Tax Agencies
          • RJS LAW Approach to Collections
          • IRS Statute of Limitations on Collections
          • Streamlined Installment Agreements
          • Tax Penalty Abatement
          • Taxpayer Assistance Orders TAO
        • IRS Payroll Tax
          • Independent Contractor Reclassification Audits
          • IRS Forms 940 and 941
          • IRS Trust Fund Interviews
          • Payroll Tax Liability Payment Options
          • Trust Fund Recovery Penalties
        • IRS Wealth Squad
        • Offer in Compromise & Tax Settlements
          • OVERVIEW OF OFFER IN COMPROMISE PROCESS
          • The Offer in Compromise Process
          • Appealing an Offer in Compromise to the IRS
          • How does the IRS evaluate an Offer in Compromise
          • Offer in Compromise and Dissipated Assets
          • Offer in Compromise Requirements
          • Pros and Cons of an Offer in Compromise
          • Why Choose RJS LAW?
          • Offer in Compromise Alternatives
          • Actual IRS Offer in Compromise Results
      • STATE TAX MATTERS
        • EDD California Payroll Tax Lawyer
          • EDD Investigations
          • EDD Collections – Liens, Levies, and Garnishments
        • CDTFA – California Sales Tax
          • California Sales Tax Appeals
          • California Sales Tax Audits
          • California Department Of Tax And Fee Administration – CDTFA
        • California State Tax Matters – California Franchise Tax Board | FTB | EDD
          • California Residency Audits
          • Discharging State Income Taxes in Bankruptcy
          • State Tax Practice – Outside of California
      • CRIMINAL TAX ISSUES
        • Criminal Investigation Division
        • IRS Criminal Investigation Division Tactics
        • Criminal Tax Defense – Tax Crimes
        • Currency Transaction Records & Suspicious Activity Reports
        • IRS Methods of Proof: Tax Fraud and Evasion
        • Methods IRS Agents Use to Locate Assets
        • IRS Special Agent Visits
        • Are You a Criminal Investigation Target?
        • Criminal Tax Attorney vs. White Collar Defense
      • CORPORATE TAXES
      • TAX COURT LITIGATION
      • Innocent Spouse Relief
    • International Tax
    • Estate Planning
    • Trust Litigation
    • Trust, Estate & Probate Litigation
    • Trust & Estate Administration
    • Probate
    • Bankruptcy
      • Bankruptcy (FAQ’s)
    • Civil Litigation
    • Criminal Defense
    • Accidents & Injury
    • Corporate & Transactional
    • Private Wealth Services
    • Real Estate Law
      • Landlord Tenant Law
    • Employment Law
  • Tax Institute
    • 10th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Institute
    • 9th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Institute
    • 8th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Controversy Institute – July 28th, 2023
    • 7th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Controversy Institute – July 15th 2022
    • 6th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Controversy Institute
    • 5th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Controversy Institute
    • 4th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Controversy Institute
  • Testimonials
  • Giving
    • Giving
    • RJS LAW Donates Billboard to the Girl Scouts
  • Awards
    • Awards
    • Ronson J. Shamoun at events with various dignitaries
    • SD50 Extraordinary Leadership
    • Media
    • Video Gallery
  • Blog
  • Pay
  • Contact
  • en English
    • en English
    • es Español

WINNER OF THE UNION TRIBUNE SAN DIEGO'S BEST TAX LAW FIRM

 


9 YEARS

Call
Contact
Blog
  • Home
  • About
    • Ronson J. Shamoun, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Chandara Diep, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Devon J. Arabo, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Brian M. Malloy, Esq.
    • Andrea Cisneros Valdez, Esq., LL.M.
    • Sam Imandoust, ESQ., LL.M
    • Lauren Suarez, ESQ., LL.M.
    • John I. Forry, Esq.
    • Martin Schainbaum, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Kaveh Imandoust, JD, MBT, CPA
    • Joseph Cole, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Christopher Engelmann, ESQ., LL.M.
    • Remy Hogan, Esq., LL.M.
    • Steve S. Mattia, Esq.
    • Dod Ghassemkhani, ESQ.
    • Vincent Renda, Esq.
    • Pedro Bernal, Esq.
    • Sabri P. Shamoun 1938-2023
    • Melanie M. Shamoun
    • Renae Arabo
    • Hilary Dargavell
    • Sandie Portilla
    • Lupita C. Torres
    • Jewell Cornejo
    • Kesia Belford
    • Danielle N. Misleh
    • Judith G. Jeremie, JD
    • Rebecca Shuman
    • Michael Lutzky, CPA
    • Gianna Iskander
  • Practices
    • Tax
      • IRS TAX MATTERS
        • IRS Appeals
          • IRS Appeals Process
          • Contesting an IRS Levy
          • Why Retain RJS LAW for IRS Appeals
          • 4 Tips For Navigating The IRS Rapid Appeals Process
        • IRS AUDITS
          • IRS Correspondence Audits
          • What are IRS Field Audits?
          • Initial IRS Compliance Center Audits
          • IRS Office Audits
          • What happens in an IRS Audit?
          • Taxpayer Rights Under IRS Publication 1
          • IRS Warns Taxpayers About Scam
        • NOTICES
          • IRS Notices
          • IRS Letters
          • FTB Notices
          • Avisos en Español
        • IRS Collections
          • Avoiding and Eliminating IRS Tax Liens
          • Collection Due Process Hearing
          • CP 501 – IRS Notice
          • Failure to file a tax return: What happens?
          • How the IRS calculates interest
          • How to get a tax levy released
          • ACS – Automated Collection System
          • IRS Collections Process
          • IRS Interest Abatement
          • IRS Revenue Officers
          • Jeopardy Assessments and Jeopardy Levies
          • National Tax Agencies
          • RJS LAW Approach to Collections
          • IRS Statute of Limitations on Collections
          • Streamlined Installment Agreements
          • Tax Penalty Abatement
          • Taxpayer Assistance Orders TAO
        • IRS Payroll Tax
          • Independent Contractor Reclassification Audits
          • IRS Forms 940 and 941
          • IRS Trust Fund Interviews
          • Payroll Tax Liability Payment Options
          • Trust Fund Recovery Penalties
        • IRS Wealth Squad
        • Offer in Compromise & Tax Settlements
          • OVERVIEW OF OFFER IN COMPROMISE PROCESS
          • The Offer in Compromise Process
          • Appealing an Offer in Compromise to the IRS
          • How does the IRS evaluate an Offer in Compromise
          • Offer in Compromise and Dissipated Assets
          • Offer in Compromise Requirements
          • Pros and Cons of an Offer in Compromise
          • Why Choose RJS LAW?
          • Offer in Compromise Alternatives
          • Actual IRS Offer in Compromise Results
      • STATE TAX MATTERS
        • EDD California Payroll Tax Lawyer
          • EDD Investigations
          • EDD Collections – Liens, Levies, and Garnishments
        • CDTFA – California Sales Tax
          • California Sales Tax Appeals
          • California Sales Tax Audits
          • California Department Of Tax And Fee Administration – CDTFA
        • California State Tax Matters – California Franchise Tax Board | FTB | EDD
          • California Residency Audits
          • Discharging State Income Taxes in Bankruptcy
          • State Tax Practice – Outside of California
      • CRIMINAL TAX ISSUES
        • Criminal Investigation Division
        • IRS Criminal Investigation Division Tactics
        • Criminal Tax Defense – Tax Crimes
        • Currency Transaction Records & Suspicious Activity Reports
        • IRS Methods of Proof: Tax Fraud and Evasion
        • Methods IRS Agents Use to Locate Assets
        • IRS Special Agent Visits
        • Are You a Criminal Investigation Target?
        • Criminal Tax Attorney vs. White Collar Defense
      • CORPORATE TAXES
      • TAX COURT LITIGATION
      • Innocent Spouse Relief
    • International Tax
    • Estate Planning
    • Trust Litigation
    • Trust, Estate & Probate Litigation
    • Trust & Estate Administration
    • Probate
    • Bankruptcy
      • Bankruptcy (FAQ’s)
    • Civil Litigation
    • Criminal Defense
    • Accidents & Injury
    • Corporate & Transactional
    • Private Wealth Services
    • Real Estate Law
      • Landlord Tenant Law
    • Employment Law
  • Tax Institute
    • 10th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Institute
    • 9th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Institute
    • 8th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Controversy Institute – July 28th, 2023
    • 7th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Controversy Institute – July 15th 2022
    • 6th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Controversy Institute
    • 5th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Controversy Institute
    • 4th Annual USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Controversy Institute
  • Testimonials
  • Giving
    • Giving
    • RJS LAW Donates Billboard to the Girl Scouts
  • Awards
    • Awards
    • Ronson J. Shamoun at events with various dignitaries
    • SD50 Extraordinary Leadership
    • Media
    • Video Gallery
  • Blog
  • Pay
  • Contact

Leave a Comment

Classifying Workers in California – Contractor vs. Employee

contractor vs. employee

Easier Access to Labor Complicates Workers’ EDD Classification – Contractor vs. Employee

You are an innovator. You have identified an underserved market, developed an application to facilitate the supply of the desired services, and found a pool of suppliers with the flexibility and motivation to provide such services. Now you can relax and let the invisible hand work its magic, or can you? You do not have to worry about contractor vs. employee classification, or do you? 

Well, life is not that simple, especially not in the wonderful state of California. Although you might see yourself simply as the middleman, connecting suppliers with consumers, the Employment Development Department (“EDD”) might consider you an employer with certain obligations to your labor “suppliers.”

Classifying workers as employees or independent contractors is one of the major headaches for companies – especially those operating in California. The development of service applications, such as Uber, Lyft, and Postmates, has created a high demand for services and provided employment for people seeking or needing flexible work. However, these developments in the market have also given rise to employment and tax law dilemmas, especially regarding independent contractor vs. employee classification.

What is AB-5?

In California, the enactment of Assembly Bill 5, commonly known as “AB-5,” has been the subject of great controversy, particularly within the tech industry. AB-5, which became law on January 1, 2020, revised the Borrello test by introducing the “ABC” test to determine an employee’s status and classification. Although the tech industry expressed the loudest opposition to this law, AB-5 has had repercussions in numerous and less conspicuous industries that have traditionally relied on independent contractors.  

Under AB-5, workers are generally considered employees unless they meet all three conditions of the “ABC” test:

  1. The person is independent of the hiring organization in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of the work and in fact.
  2. The person performs work that is outside the hiring entity’s business.
  3. The person is routinely doing work in an independently established trade, occupation, or business that is the same as the work being requested and performed

The underlying factor in this test is the hiring entity’s control over the worker. If the worker only works for the hiring entity and the hiring entity directs the performance of the work, attempting to establish the independence of this worker will be extremely difficult.

Additionally, it is extremely important to remember that workers are considered employees by default, regardless of any agreements that might state otherwise. Therefore, the hiring entity has the burden to prove that the worker is in fact an independent contractor.  

Who is exempt from AB-5?

Luckily, there are numerous exceptions to AB-5. Proposition 22, which was approved by most California residents, exempts app-based drivers for network companies if the companies meet the conditions listed in Section 7451 of the Business and Professions Code. Primarily, these conditions address the network companies’ control over the drivers.

Currently, newspaper carriers and distributors are also exempt but only until January 1, 2022.

In other instances, the Industrial Welfare Commission, the Labor Code, and the Unemployment Insurance code explicitly define employment relationships that may be exempt from the ABC test.

Additionally, a worker could be classified as an independent contractor through the Borello multifactor test. This test takes into consideration several factors including, but not limited to, the worker’s investment in equipment, the need for special skills, the level of hiring entity’s direction over performance, and the parties’ perception regarding their employment relationship. When a court declares an exception to the ABC test, this multifactor test governs the determination of a worker’s classification in the applicable circumstances.

AB-2257, which modifies and increases exceptions to the ABC test and expands the use of the Borello test, went into effect on September 04, 2020. Under AB-2257, additional occupations and employment relationships are now able to use the Borello test, instead of the ABC test, to determine worker classifications if certain conditions are met. The new exceptions include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • Business-to-business contracting relationships
  • Referral agency and service provider relationships
  • Contracts for professional services
  • Single-engagement event contracts between two individuals
  • Contracts with individual performance artists

In essence, AB-2257 relieved some of the tension created by AB-5 in the employment sector. However, it must be emphasized that numerous conditions must be met to bypass the ABC test and alternatively apply the Borello test. Although AB-5 may now be less intimidating, employers are advised to review and comply with both AB-5 and AB-2257 before making any independent contractor vs. employee determinations.

Why does worker classification matter?

As an employer, you have certain responsibilities toward your employees and the state. These responsibilities include paying California’s Unemployment Insurance and Employment Training Taxes, in addition to federal taxes. Also, you are required to obtain worker’s compensation insurance and, in certain situations, offer health insurance to your employees. Additionally, you are required to follow minimum wage and overtime regulations, and offer rest and meal breaks to your employees.

Hiring solely independent contractors is immensely desirable because the tax and insurance burden shifts from the hiring entity to the independent contractor. However, misclassifying workers purposely or unintentionally can result in multiple penalties and lawsuits.

Worker classification can be a complicated and costly matter, especially in highly regulated states like California. Nevertheless, do not let worker classification crush your entrepreneurial spirit!

If you are currently an employer facing issues regarding employee misclassification, reach out to the RJS Team as it is vital to have an updated independent contractor agreement in place before venturing into a non-employee relationship. RJS Law and its team of attorneys have the skills and experience to advise you regarding your situation and in drafting and reviewing independent contractor agreements.  RJS Law can also represent you before the EDD or IRS if you are being audited.

Published by Marcel Garcia

About US


Subscribe To Our Blog & Future Updates

Opt In To RJS LAW

Email Address

Filed Under: California AB5, Contractor vs Employee Tagged With: AB5, California AB5, Contractor vs Employee

RJS LAW

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe To RJS LAW

Email Address

Contact Us

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Recent Posts

  • U.S. Withdrawal from the Global Minimum Tax: Implications for Multinational Compliance and International Tax Stability
  • Understanding the Proposed $5 Million “Gold Card” Visa and Its Implications for High-Net-Worth Immigrants
  • Is the Gold Card Visa Legal? A Breakdown of the Proposal’s Path Through Congress

Categories

  • Advance Child Tax Credit
  • Asset Protection
  • Bank Fraud
  • Bankruptcy
  • Bankruptcy Attorney
  • Bankruptcy Laws
  • Beneficial Ownership Information
  • Bypass Trust
  • California AB5
  • California Payroll Taxes
  • California Sales Tax
  • Cannabis Tax
  • CARES Act
  • Cash Payments
  • Charitable Trust
  • Child Tax Credit
  • Company News
  • Contractor vs Employee
  • Contracts
  • Coronavirus
  • Court Settlements
  • COVID-19
  • CP14 Notice
  • CP504
  • CP504B
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Cryptocurrency Taxes
  • Digital Assets
  • E-Commerce
  • Economic Stimulus
  • EDD
  • EDD Audit
  • EDD Audit Penalties
  • Employee Retention Credit
  • Employment Law
  • ERTC
  • Estate Planning
  • Estate Planning Litigation
  • Excise Taxes
  • Exemption Planning
  • FBAR
  • FBAR Penalties
  • FBAR Reporting
  • Filing Bankruptcy
  • Financial Reporting
  • FinCEN
  • Foreign Bank Account
  • Foreign Bank Accounts
  • Form 105
  • Form 5471
  • Form 8300
  • FTB Audits
  • FTB Collections
  • FTB Issues
  • FTB Penalties
  • Gambling Tax
  • Gaming Losses
  • Gereration Skipping Trusts
  • Gold Card Visa
  • Guardianship
  • Hiring a tax attorney
  • Homestead Exemption
  • How to Declare the Child Tax Credit
  • How-To Legal Advice
  • Inflation Reduction Act of 2022
  • Intellectual Property
  • International Tax
  • International Tax Attorney
  • International Tax Law for Non-Profits
  • International Tax Reporting Requirements
  • IRS
  • IRS Appeals
  • IRS Audits
  • IRS Collections
  • IRS CP14 Notice
  • IRS Deadlines
  • IRS Form 8833
  • IRS Forms Explained
  • IRS Issues
  • IRS News
  • IRS Notice of Tax Lien
  • IRS Notices
  • IRS OVDI
  • IRS Penalties
  • IRS Website
  • Jobs Act
  • Levies
  • Liens
  • Lottery Taxes
  • Mail Fraud
  • Masters in Taxation – LL.M.
  • No Worries ®
  • Offer in Compromise
  • Opportunity Zone
  • Penalties for Filing Late
  • PPP Loan
  • Probate
  • Property Tax Assessment
  • Proposition 19
  • Publicly Traded Partnership
  • Required Minimum Distribution
  • Restaurant Sales Tax
  • Retaliation Claims
  • Retirement
  • Revocable Trust
  • Rewards Program
  • RJS LAW In The Community
  • Sales Tax
  • Sales Tax Audit
  • San Diego Law Firm
  • SBOE Audits
  • SBOE Issues
  • Self Employment
  • Small Business
  • Stock Buyback
  • Stock Options
  • Stock Repurchase
  • Streamlined Procedures
  • Student Loans
  • Tax and Vice
  • Tax Attorney
  • Tax Brackets
  • Tax Controversy Institute
  • Tax Credit
  • Tax Cuts
  • Tax Deduction
  • Tax Deductions
  • Tax Delinquency List
  • Tax Gap
  • Tax Institute
  • Tax Law
  • Tax Liens
  • Tax on Social Media Influencers
  • Tax Penalties
  • Tax Planning
  • Tax Rates
  • Tax Tips
  • Taxation of Rewards
  • Taxes
  • The American Rescue Plan Act of 2021
  • Third Party Settlement Organizations
  • Trust
  • Trust Litigation
  • Trusts
  • U.S. Supreme Court
  • Uncategorized
  • Unemployment
  • USD School of Law – RJS LAW Tax Controversy Institute
  • Vape Taxes
  • W-8 Forms
  • Wage Garnishment
  • Wills

Footer

Legal Resources

  • Payments
  • Services
  • Tax Law Blog
  • Video Gallery

SAN DIEGO

Map & Directions
FREE Underground parking in building

303 A Street
Suite 400
San Diego, CA 92101

Phone No.
(619) 595-1655

El CAJON

Map & Directions

900 N. Cuyamaca St., Suite 101
El Cajon, CA 92020

Phone No.
(619) 777-7700

RJS LAW Tax

Areas We Serve

– Del Mar
– Coronado
– La Jolla
– La Mesa
– Chula Vista
– Escondido
– San Marcos
– Carlsbad
– Oceanside

 


©2025 | RJS LAW Firm | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy